There's nothing wrong with being weird; St. Louis should try it
This column was originally published in the St. Louis Post Dispatch on August 2, 2007.
Sitting in rush hour traffic the other day, I heard a radio host mention that the staff of Fast Company magazine had labeled St. Louis one of the world's slowest cities. In one section of the magazine's "Fast Cities" special report, St. Louis was described as "too normal for its own good."
The magazine grouped cities in broad categories: fast cities, too-fast cities, slow cities and cities on the verge. The staff's obviously subjective judgments were drawn from raw statistics and information from such groups as the Institute for the Future, Sustain Lane and CEOs for Cities.
That last group produces something called a CityVitals survey, in which St. Louis ranked, as the magazine put it, "dead last on [the] 'Weirdness Index,' a measure of passion and engagement."
I was disappointed. I know St. Louis tends to be considered socially conservative, but I wondered how weird we're supposed to be.
So I took a closer look at the CityVitals report. It compares the performance of 50 American metropolitan areas in what it calls "four key areas: talent, innovation, connections and distinctiveness." In the Distinctive City category, St. Louis was 50th out of 50 on the Weirdness Index. The index, in turn, is drawn from market research data on 75 different activities and the degree to which a metro area exceeds or falls short of the national norm. (There's a "norm" for weirdness?)
But I was drawn back to the way Fast Company had described the Weirdness Index as a measure of "passion and engagement."
Passion and engagement relate to our work as well as to our personal lives. Passion is a key to developing one's talents and skills for work that is energizing and satisfying. Engagement is the level at which one plays. How accurate these words are in describing us says a lot about whether we are making life happen or letting it happen.
Abraham Maslow, the psychologist and creator of the Hierarchy of Needs, argued that life consists of a series of choices. "You will either step forward into growth or step backward into safety," he wrote. To live to our fullest potential, he maintained, we must be willing to risk making choices based on who we might become, rather than staying safe in who we are.
Haven't we all dreamed of a fuller life, only to be restrained by comfort and security when the time came to actually do something about it? Every day we make choices that can contribute to our personal growth, but making such choices often means accepting the risk that others might label us weird for doing so. A lot of us retreat to safety instead.
Maybe saying that St. Louis is too normal or that it lacks passion and engagement describes at a collective level the same thing we do as individuals. As a region, maybe we've chosen safety a few too many times.
There are other cities on Fast Company's list of slow cities: Budapest, Havana, Detroit, New Orleans. It would't be too difficult to point to ways in which St. Louis isn't so bad - compared to them.
But that isn't the point. As a region and as individuals, do we really aspire to be "not so bad" as something or someone else, or do we want to be the most passionate and engaged people and community we can be?
Maybe we need to stop being afraid of being weird and think of weirdness as a passionate engagement in life.
Sitting in rush hour traffic the other day, I heard a radio host mention that the staff of Fast Company magazine had labeled St. Louis one of the world's slowest cities. In one section of the magazine's "Fast Cities" special report, St. Louis was described as "too normal for its own good."
The magazine grouped cities in broad categories: fast cities, too-fast cities, slow cities and cities on the verge. The staff's obviously subjective judgments were drawn from raw statistics and information from such groups as the Institute for the Future, Sustain Lane and CEOs for Cities.
That last group produces something called a CityVitals survey, in which St. Louis ranked, as the magazine put it, "dead last on [the] 'Weirdness Index,' a measure of passion and engagement."
I was disappointed. I know St. Louis tends to be considered socially conservative, but I wondered how weird we're supposed to be.
So I took a closer look at the CityVitals report. It compares the performance of 50 American metropolitan areas in what it calls "four key areas: talent, innovation, connections and distinctiveness." In the Distinctive City category, St. Louis was 50th out of 50 on the Weirdness Index. The index, in turn, is drawn from market research data on 75 different activities and the degree to which a metro area exceeds or falls short of the national norm. (There's a "norm" for weirdness?)
But I was drawn back to the way Fast Company had described the Weirdness Index as a measure of "passion and engagement."
Passion and engagement relate to our work as well as to our personal lives. Passion is a key to developing one's talents and skills for work that is energizing and satisfying. Engagement is the level at which one plays. How accurate these words are in describing us says a lot about whether we are making life happen or letting it happen.
Abraham Maslow, the psychologist and creator of the Hierarchy of Needs, argued that life consists of a series of choices. "You will either step forward into growth or step backward into safety," he wrote. To live to our fullest potential, he maintained, we must be willing to risk making choices based on who we might become, rather than staying safe in who we are.
Haven't we all dreamed of a fuller life, only to be restrained by comfort and security when the time came to actually do something about it? Every day we make choices that can contribute to our personal growth, but making such choices often means accepting the risk that others might label us weird for doing so. A lot of us retreat to safety instead.
Maybe saying that St. Louis is too normal or that it lacks passion and engagement describes at a collective level the same thing we do as individuals. As a region, maybe we've chosen safety a few too many times.
There are other cities on Fast Company's list of slow cities: Budapest, Havana, Detroit, New Orleans. It would't be too difficult to point to ways in which St. Louis isn't so bad - compared to them.
But that isn't the point. As a region and as individuals, do we really aspire to be "not so bad" as something or someone else, or do we want to be the most passionate and engaged people and community we can be?
Maybe we need to stop being afraid of being weird and think of weirdness as a passionate engagement in life.


Dear Maria Rodgers O'Rourke, I really loved your article! I am a graduate from a local university (cum laude), and I am perfectly normal and have a respectable job. I kind of miss my college days, and all of the free-spiritedness that went along with them. I am a big non-conformist, though, in that I never followed the "herd" mentality of my peers, (ie-I was the guy sitting admist the yuppies in my math classes, with my long hair, earrings, and Pink Floyd T-shirt.) I was married, and I have a daughter in her 20's now. My claim to fame, I guess, is I absolutely love to wear nail polish, usually black on the fingers, and chrome on the toes. This is not a joke, by the way. It all started back in high school, I guess, when the girls thought I was cool because I let them try out different colors of nail polish on me, this was just when the rock and roll crowd really started doing nail polish. I am 100% straight, and wearing nail polish doesn't have a darn thing to do with "gayness" or anything like that. Heck, Dave Beckham, the multi-millionaire soccer player, he and his wife routinely go out and get matching mani/pedi-cures. My first wife was a bit squeamish about anything out of the ordinary, and my current love of my life absolutely adores it when we wear matching nail polish when going out on the town, and we get tons of compliments on it. So, in conclusion, I just wish to say I loved your article, and I really agree that more people should break out of the norm and have some fun with their life! Thank You! Tony, aka ozzy_isgod@yahoo.com
Reply to this